skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Owners are really nice and helpful. Great pizza choices to.
Carol Loughlin via google.com - May 27, 2020
This place is great, always friendly staff. The food is always good. The only complaint i have is the wait time, but it really isn't that bad at all. Really though, come here and try their menu. Especially the mac and cheese pizza creation (forgot name). And smoothies! Love me the smoothies ... read more
DJ Heredia via google.com - Feb 22, 2020
Fantastic Food, awesome staff, the owners are awesome and the give a lot to the community ♥️ ... read more
Brenda B via google.com - Feb 20, 2020
Great food. Friendly but slow service.
Adam DeWitt via google.com - Feb 8, 2020
The cheesy bites are amazing! And the Italian salad is a great meal! If you haven’t been there recently give it a try, the new menu options are totally new for our area, like macaroni and cheeses pizza, even build your own macaroni and cheese topped pizza! 😋 ... read more
Tonya Ringuette via google.com - Jan 22, 2020
This is an amazing place to eat! ...
This is an amazing place to eat! My son and I love the cheesy bits and macaroni and cheese pizza!
T R. via yelp.com - Jan 22, 2020
We love it
My son loves going to eat here! The sheesh bites are amazing! And Macaroni and cheese on a pizza! In the UP! With buffalo chicken and blue cheese...
tarbox2284 via tripadvisor.com - Jan 22, 2020
What a great place to get food from. So many wonderful options on the menu.
Lisa Mixter via google.com - Dec 11, 2019
Great food!
Josh Fisher via google.com - Dec 2, 2019
Fast service, excellent pizza.
Rod Prusi via google.com - Oct 11, 2019
You have to try the garlic and parmesan chicken wings! Outstanding ... read more
Jill Howard via google.com - Oct 8, 2019
They went out of their way to make the pizza the way we wanted it!
Ellen Hook via google.com - Sep 21, 2019
While visiting the UP from Tennessee my fiancee and I ate here twice, as I am a pizza connoisseur. The food was particularly good and will be back when I am up there again.
Jonathan Hammons via google.com - Sep 6, 2019
Beautiful location right on Teal Lake! Enjoy the view of the lake while eating on the back deck. First time trying a cudighi sandwich. Was delicious!
Brian Hilliker via google.com - Aug 11, 2019
Pizza was amazing. White Piazza was phenomenal.
TheHamlinHooker Resistance via google.com - Aug 6, 2019
Great menu.
Jim Norton via google.com - Jul 20, 2019
Two orders of cheesey bites later and 6 people were happily satisfied! These orders were huge and for $30, everyone had plenty and still nearly an entire box of leftovers. Would have given 5 stars but the fellas were a tad heavy handed with the jalapenos. Mouths were ON FIRE. They were still yummy though and nearly as good the next d ... read more
Beth Blake via google.com - Jul 3, 2019
Very Good Award Winning Cudighi!
Had to try one since they won the best Cudighi in a recent competition. The sausage patty had a burger-like consistency and the flavor was great, and the mushroom, peppers, onion toppings were worked really well, as did the tomato sauce and cheese. Think they...More ... read more
Steve N via tripadvisor.com - Jul 1, 2019
Pretty good cudighi, and the right price
Teal Lake Pizzeria won the 1st Annual Cudighi Cook Off last weekend, so I figured I'd give it a try. I got the cudighi with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, cheese, and red sauce, and it came with a choice of chips or coleslaw, all for...More ... read more
David P via tripadvisor.com - Jun 5, 2019
Good food. Mozzarella stick are horrible hope they find somewhere else to purchase them from. Would like more sides to offer with the food.
Tamara Isley via google.com - May 20, 2019
Amazing fresh made pizzas!
PS4 MoonWarz via google.com - Apr 24, 2019
Ok pizza and good wings ... read more
Denise Brooks via google.com - Apr 4, 2019
This is my first time ordering ...
This is my first time ordering from there and I was not disappointed.  I had ordered two Hematite steak out for me and a co worker and a order of mozzarella sticks...  It was delicious.  I will be ordering again from there and the fact they deliver to Ishpeming is fantastic.
Lola G. via yelp.com - Feb 26, 2019
Good food ... read more
chet barto via google.com - Jan 26, 2019
Delicious pizza handmade from an uplifting happy small buisness ... read more
Austin Cade via google.com - Jan 17, 2019
Great pizza, they're always helpful and sweet!
Dan Paavola via google.com - Jan 4, 2019
Great service, fantastic food! Perfect place to bring the family for dinner or order lunch on the go! They're quick with great prices!
Bruce Whitehead via google.com - Dec 21, 2018
Great pizza in a great location, with a fast and friendly staff! The menu is very extensive featuring unique sandwiches and pizzas. Try the homemade cudighi on a sandwich or your pizza. The best I've ever had.
Amy Flanagan via google.com - Oct 12, 2018
We got a large sausage and pepperoni ...
We got a large sausage and pepperoni pizza. The pizza smelled amazing before we even opened it up and we were not disappointed! Plenty of toppings and the pizza tasted great! Definitely check them out! Nice staff and nice place right on teal lake.
Doug H. via yelp.com - Oct 6, 2018
This will be our new go-to spot on trips across the UP!
ed evans via google.com - Sep 21, 2018
Awesome food! Love the pineapple piggy!! ❤ Get atmosphere, and kid friendly. This will be one of our regular places to eat out.
Katie Prisk via google.com - Sep 20, 2018
Delicious high quality food. I eat here at least once a week, and am never dissapointed.
Kyla via google.com - Sep 5, 2018
Great pizza good atmosphere ... read more
rane gross via google.com - Sep 5, 2018
Good pizza, friendly staff, and a cute deck right on the lake. Will definitely be back!
Ryan Connelly via google.com - Aug 15, 2018
So much more than just great pizza! We've been working our way through the extensive menu because we want to try it all! Everything we've had has been amazing and the service is top-notch too! The online ordering is very easy for both carry-out and delivery. You simply can't go wrong with whatever you order, it's all delicious!
thylacine701 via google.com - Aug 12, 2018
The food, service, and pricing were all awesome. We tried the jalapeño bacon cheesy bites and the
The food, service, and pricing were all awesome. We tried the jalapeño bacon cheesy bites and the Thai bites, Thai was our favorite but both were great. We had the steak lovers pizza and we would order it again. The garlic cream sauce made the pizza. The staff was so nice and friendly and we were lucky to have a nice evening so w ... read more
Michele Simms via facebook.com - Jul 23, 2018
Great pizza and even better customer service,we will be going back!!
Edward Karki via google.com - Jul 14, 2018
Fun flavors and great food and service!
Fun flavors and great food and service!
Kirsten Matthews via facebook.com - Jul 13, 2018
Good food ... read more
Jimmy Joseph via google.com - Jun 30, 2018
This restaurant offers delicious ...
This restaurant offers delicious sandwiches, salads, and what they call "bites." We've ordered from them numerous times for delivery and the choices are great, the service is great, and delivery time is reasonable and friendly. They've always been delicious, and the one time we had an order that was wrong they quickly offered a refun ... read more
Rachel C. via yelp.com - Jun 23, 2018
Used the pizza card for a large pepperoni and thought the pizza was very good. Can’t wait to try s
Used the pizza card for a large pepperoni and thought the pizza was very good. Can’t wait to try some other menu items!
Justin Stephens via facebook.com - Jun 13, 2018
The food is fresh, homemade and delicious! The staff is friendly and extremely helpful!
The food is fresh, homemade and delicious! The staff is friendly and extremely helpful!
Teri LaBo Gillotte via facebook.com - Jun 9, 2018
The next pizza i'v had in long time. Delivery was fast and friendly I highly recommend everyone to try thier wide variety of food ... read more
Heidi Schwan via google.com - Jun 8, 2018
I have been wanting to check this place out since it opened. I had the chance to today, and was ver
I have been wanting to check this place out since it opened. I had the chance to today, and was very pleased. I will be back.
Shawn Hodgins via facebook.com - Jun 3, 2018
Everything was excellent! We enjoyed it very much. Wonderful service with awesome owners. We look f
Everything was excellent! We enjoyed it very much. Wonderful service with awesome owners. We look forward to going back very soon!
Jen Mathias Hodgins via facebook.com - Jun 3, 2018
Great food, excellent service, the owners made you feel right at home.
kirk johnson via google.com - May 18, 2018
Service was fast, and the food was really good! The bites are huge!
Service was fast, and the food was really good! The bites are huge!
Tonya Rae Ann via facebook.com - May 16, 2018
I've eaten here twice now and both times I've been extremely impressed! The Thai bites and the pesto bites are both wonderful! Their pizza dough has a hint of garlic in it and tastes really good! I don't usually eat pizza crust but I do with their pizza because I enjoy the flavor of their crust! I appreciate the diverse menu choices ... read more
Sarah Santiago via google.com - Apr 22, 2018
Great food and great service! Even had a keto friendly pizza made special for me. It was delicious
Great food and great service! Even had a keto friendly pizza made special for me. It was delicious and I can't wait to go back.
Cheryl A. McCoy via facebook.com - Apr 15, 2018
I recommend one of their specialty pizzas! I tried the white pizza and was pleasantly surprised! I'
I recommend one of their specialty pizzas! I tried the white pizza and was pleasantly surprised! I've tried a plain cheese pizza and a specialty and the specialty definitely hit the spot when you're looking to try something different! The plain cheese missed the mark a bit for me mainly due to the crust, but I'm pretty fixed on the ... read more
Amber Wetton via facebook.com - Apr 2, 2018
Incredible service, good prices and most importantly delicious pizza!!! I enjoyed it for the first
Incredible service, good prices and most importantly delicious pizza!!! I enjoyed it for the first time today; but it will not be the last. Pretty big menu, too! They honored my Local 3 Pizza Club card; and I ordered a chicken pizza and added carmelized onions and mushrooms. Mmm, delicious! Thank you!
Matt Manninen via facebook.com - Mar 9, 2018
Omg..ordered for the first time tonite..yummo!!! Kids loved pizza and bites! Thank you!!!
Omg..ordered for the first time tonite..yummo!!! Kids loved pizza and bites! Thank you!!!
Kelley Beatty Delongchamp via facebook.com - Mar 6, 2018
Such a diverse menu and all of the choices are delicious!
Jessie Moore via google.com - Feb 26, 2018
LOVE the GF crust and the fact you made me pizza bites with it. Thank you!!
LOVE the GF crust and the fact you made me pizza bites with it. Thank you!!
Amanda Belcher Klumpp via facebook.com - Feb 23, 2018
Glad to have a variety of sandwiches, pizza, bites, and salads available.
Glad to have a variety of sandwiches, pizza, bites, and salads available.
Jaime Racine Green via facebook.com - Feb 23, 2018
We had the calzone and the Grilled Italian sandwich and they were both delicious! The service was excellent. I recommend Teal Lake Pizzeria. Can't wait to give something else a try.
Debbie Gregorich via google.com - Feb 8, 2018
Fast delivery to ishpeming. Awesome food. Same cheese bites as paisanos! Definitely recommend!
Fast delivery to ishpeming. Awesome food. Same cheese bites as paisanos! Definitely recommend!
Jordan-Natalie Degenaer via facebook.com - Jan 27, 2018
We just bought a house in Negaunee after living in Marquette for a long time and being loyal to a f
We just bought a house in Negaunee after living in Marquette for a long time and being loyal to a few different pizza joints there. I must say I really enjoyed the pizza! I will be ordering here again soon. The sauce was awesome and they put a ton of toppings and cheese! Great job Teal Lake Pizzeria! I wish you the best of luck and y ... read more
Zac Couvillion via facebook.com - Jan 17, 2018
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip Advisor